Email Marketing RulesThe Last Word on September 2021
Posted on October 7, 2021
A roundup of email marketing articles, posts, and tweets you might have missed last month…
Must-read articles, posts & reports
Email for All report (Action Rocket and Beyond the Envelope)
Skinny Santa: Salesforce Expects Higher Costs, Fewer Online Orders This Holiday Season (MediaPost)
Insightful & entertaining tweets
Copywriting is like a joke: if you have to explain it, it’s probably not good.
— Robert Davidson 💌♻️ (@dobertravidson) September 23, 2021
See something new every day pic.twitter.com/Rnlh5RK9Un
— 𝔸𝕃𝔼𝕏 (@alexcwilliams) September 24, 2021
The holidays are for gift-giving. It’s time to rethink your personalisation strategy.
➡️ don’t only personalise based previous shopping or browse data
➡️ also recommend products outside the typical range
➡️ send gift-giving inspiration— Kate Barrett eFocus (@eFocus_marketin) September 28, 2021
Noteworthy subject lines
Really Good Emails, 9/9 – Do you want to be our CEO?
Burlington, 9/8 – Our Nationwide Hiring Event starts soon! Apply today.
Big Lots, 9/12 – We’re hiring! Check out the perks!
Petco, 9/2 – 20% off your local pickup! Includes dog and cat food!
Hobby Lobby, 9/7 – NEW Christmas Arrivals! 40% Off 🎄
Big Lots, 9/10 – Crazy for Christmas? Sneak a peek inside!
Williams Sonoma, 9/17 – First look: our one-stop shop for Halloween, Thanksgiving & Christmas is HERE
Office Depot, 9/2 – 🔔 Save up to 55% today, on our best-selling school supplies…
DICK’S Sporting Goods, 9/9 – Your DICK’S Sporting Goods email: time to think about school styles?
ModCloth, 9/6 – Bat news: final hours for 30% off Halloween! 🦇
The Home Depot, 9/2 – Doing Season Is Kicking Off 🏈
Wegmans Meals 2GO – We’ve Got Game Day Covered!
Williams Sonoma, 9/10 – Cozy up to autumn with our favorite meatball recipes for any occasion
Neiman Marcus, 9/6 – Sweater weather is on the way
GapCash, 9/17 – You’re getting warmer…
Nordstrom, 9/6 – The five styles to get this fall
Williams Sonoma, 9/18 – Hello, autumn hues 💛❤️🧡
GapCash, 9/18 – Sweatshirt Dress + Tie-Dye = 🧡❤️💚💙
Eddie Bauer, 9/22 – Fall = Down Puffy Weather!
Nordstrom, 9/18 – New season = new shoes
Saks Fifth Avenue, 9/10 – It’s all about pearls, sequins and quilting
Zales, 9/15 – Get the Look: Serena Williams at the 2021 Met Gala
Gap, 9/2 – 90s vibes, teen-ified
Neiman Marcus, 9/2 – New & emerging denim brands
Spotify, 9/27 – Listen to women at full volume
Patagonia, 9/6 – Old clothes, new tricks
Quiksilver, 9/12 – High impact in the water, low impact on the environment.
Patagonia, 9/17 – How are your clothes grown?
AutoZone, 9/27 – See FREE battery services near you 📍
IKEA, 9/16 – LIVE NOW: Open your doors to the IKEA Festival!
Burlington, 9/15 – It’s National Hispanic Heritage Month!
Kohl’s, 9/23 – Celebrate Hispanic Heritage Month in style.
Neiman Marcus, 9/24 – Spotlight on diversity
Express, 9/8 – The group chat is 😍 over these wedding outfits
Petco Love, 9/8 — $1M in lifesaving funds: share your 🐶 🐱 🐰 story
New posts on EmailMarketingRules.com
Email Privacy ‘Regulation’ in the Age of Big Tech
Holiday Marketing Quarterly: Fourth Quarter 2021 Checklist
Hide My Email Elevates Risks of Temporary Email Addresses
Apple’s MPP May Drive Email Design Changes that Actually Hurt Customer Engagement
Dyspatch: Modular Email Design – A System Built for Speed and Scale
Email Marketing’s Increasing Role as Third-Party Cookies Disappear
The Fold in the Inbox: Hard Line, Soft Line, or Imaginary Line?
Posted on October 6, 2021
Similar to how you can’t see the content below the fold of a newspaper without opening it, the email fold is that point on a screen where a subscriber can’t see any more content without scrolling. There’s been a long-simmering debate in the industry about how important this line is to email design.
Let’s break down the arguments…
Email Privacy ‘Regulation’ in the Age of Big Tech
Posted on September 28, 2021
Imagine if CASL was passed without first having a public comment period so businesses and other organizations could have their voices heard? Imagine if GDPR went into effect 3 months after it was passed instead of after a 2-year transition period? Imagine if CCPA applied to people all over the world and not just people in California?
All of that isn’t far off from what the email industry just experienced with the rollout of Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection (MPP), as SparkPost’s April Mullen and I explain in this guest post for the ANA. We also share a vision for how email marketers can work with Big Tech companies like Apple, Google, and Microsoft—which now wield just as much power as public entities when it comes to changing privacy rules and other fundamental aspects of the email channel.
Holiday Marketing Quarterly: Fourth Quarter 2021 Checklist
Posted on September 27, 2021
Oracle’s Holiday Marketing Quarterly gives B2C brands a quarter-by-quarter checklist for how to achieve more during the critical holiday season with their email marketing and other digital marketing channels. Along with guidance on planning, strategy, and prioritization, you’ll get advice and tips from some of Oracle Marketing Consulting’s more than 500 digital marketing experts.
The fourth quarter is focused on wrapping up your final prep and then taking action during the holiday season to maximize results and minimize problems. In this Holiday Marketing Quarterly, we’ll cover:
- Engaging Seasonal Buyers
- Automated Campaign Adjustments
- Leveraging New Capabilities
- Cross-Channel Coordination
- Incremental A/B Testing
- Finalizing Your Plans
For details on each of those areas…
>> Download the 13-page Fourth Quarter 2021 Holiday Marketing Quarterly
Hide My Email Elevates Risks of Temporary Email Addresses
Posted on September 24, 2021
Email marketing is a great way to build long-term relationships, but marketers have always wrestled with accepting low-value email addresses from would-be subscribers. B2C brands wonder if a subscriber has provided their primary email account or a secondary address they check far less frequently. And B2B marketers debate accepting freemail addresses or only corporate email addresses, which make lead scoring easier. While businesses can make a “something is better than nothing” argument for accepting secondary email addresses and freemail addresses, it’s harder to say the same when it comes to disposable or temporary email addresses.
That’s because you can’t build a relationship with someone who uses an email address that’s typically designed to expire within hours. Beyond cluttering up your CRM database with dead end contact data (the biggest risk), there’s also a small risk your sender reputation will be impacted since any email sent to a disposable email address after it expires hard bounces. When accepting a temporary email address, you’re banking entirely on the value of being able to deliver what’s generally a one-time transactional email, signup incentive, or content download to that person.
The impact of temporary email addresses is now more pressing because of newly released updates to Hide My Email, a privacy feature Apple is promoting alongside Mail Privacy Protection.
Apple’s MPP May Drive Email Design Changes that Actually Hurt Customer Engagement
Posted on September 9, 2021
Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection will have a broad range of effects on email marketers, impacting email analytics, design, deliverability, personalization, and optimization efforts. Sadly, subscribers who enable MPP will receive less relevant emails and more emails than they would have otherwise gotten if marketers could better measure their engagement through opens.
I also fear that Apple’s changes will cause marketers to change their messaging and design strategy to drive clicks more insistently, since opens will be unreliable for a substantial portion of their audience. This move would be understandable. With Apple generating false opens for the users of their Mail app that enable MPP, opens will become a meaningless sign for many subscribers. Marketers will want to compensate for the loss of their highest frequency engagement signal by boosting their second highest frequency engagement signal, clicks, which are currently about one-eighth as frequent as opens.
The adjustments that will be required for reengagement campaigns illustrate what may happen more broadly. For example, before MPP, the goal of a reengagement campaign was to simply get the subscriber to open the email, which would be a signal that the email address was still valid and that a live person was receiving the email. For people who enable MPP, that will be wholly inadequate, since Apple will be generating false opens for every email they receive. That means that marketers will need a stronger signal—a click—in order to be sure that the email address is safe to continue mailing to.
This need for more clicks more often could cause marketers to redesign many other emails, too. For example, companies may move valuable content from the body of their emails to landing pages in order to coax more clicks out of subscribers. This would reverse years of email design philosophy and send us backsliding toward a time when emails were postcard-style teasers to get people to visit website landing pages.
This would be bad for subscribers and marketers for three interrelated reasons…
Dyspatch: Modular Email Design – A System Built for Speed and Scale
Posted on September 8, 2021
Modular email design is on the rise. In this post by Terri Reid of Dyspatch, she talks about what modular email design is, what its benefits are, what it looks like in action, and much more.
Here at Oracle Marketing Consulting, we’re big fans of modular email architecture, so I was happy to contribute some of our learnings. For instance, our clients who implement it reduce email production time by 25% to 40%. That’s a huge time-saving. But that additional speed has been a real competitive advantage during the pandemic when business disruptions seem routine, consumer attitudes have been changing quickly, and marketing teams have become extra lean.
But as powerful as modular email design is right now, it will be even more so in the future because it will enable personalization at incredible scale. As I say in the post, “By having modular templates, marketers will be ready for a future where AI increasingly makes decisions about which content modules an individual subscriber will receive, as well as the content in them.”
For the full discussion…
The Last Word on August 2021
Posted on September 3, 2021
A roundup of email marketing articles, posts, and tweets you might have missed last month…
Must-read articles, posts & reports
What Are Stores Even Thinking With All These Emails? (The Atlantic)
The Conscientious Marketer: Don’t Send Emails to People Who Have Unsubscribed (MediaPost)
How the Pandemic Has Changed Marketing (MarketingProfs)
Why Does Microsoft Hate You? (Spam Resource)
Holiday Email Campaigns: What We Learned In 2020 & How to Prepare for 2021 (Only Influencers)
Insightful & entertaining tweets
You don’t choose the email life, the email life chooses you 💌#emailgeeks pic.twitter.com/sLBDsB1fu3
— Avi Goldman (@theavigoldman) August 17, 2021
95% of millennials say their friends are the most credible source of product information.
— Jay Baer (@jaybaer) August 17, 2021
Have we seen this email escalation piece? 😂 @metmuseum https://t.co/Aoo9UN22kn @NewYorker #emailgeeks
— Kirk Bentley (@VeryBentley) August 19, 2021
E tu, Reebok?? 😩
Re: this tactic sucks. pic.twitter.com/XCDl0q7c8p
— Val Geisler (@lovevalgeisler) August 6, 2021
Noteworthy subject lines
Burlington, 8/5 – Our Nationwide Hiring Event starts soon! Apply today.
CVS, 8/24 – Full FDA Approval for Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine.
Uncommon Goods, 8/28 – ⏰ Snag these gifts early—last year, they sold out
Target, 8/5 – Get the kids ready for school early ✏️
Gap, 8/27 – The teacher/style icon: MR JAMISON
Big Lots, 8/19 – Turn school to-do lists into TA-DA lists!
Target, 8/10 – Try out School List Assist to find & shop your class list.
Uncommon Goods, 8/17 – Dorm Style 101: How to have the coolest room at college
Bed Bath & Beyond, 8/10 – Pack & Hold: Shop online or locally. Pick up near campus!
Walgreens, 8/11 – Here’s what’s waiting @ Walgreens! A world of deals is a click away – same-day Delivery = the convenient choice.
Subway, 8/18 – FREE COOKIES. $0 DELIVERY FEE.
Uncommon Goods, 8/31 – Introducing Uncommon Experiences—a selection of hand-picked, virtual classes
Williams Sonoma, 8/24 – Now brewing: pumpkin lattes at home 🎃 ☕ (coffee makers ship FREE!)
Olive Garden, 8/26 – Your first course is always never-ending
Gap, 8/7 – Remember jeans? WE DO
Nordstrom Rack, 8/5 – Don’t miss The Denim Shop—up to 65% off
Quiksilver, 8/29 – New Rashguards Made For Chasing The Hoizon
Williams Sonoma, 8/19 – The patio bar is STILL open
REI, 8/19 – Camping Road Trips > Road Trips
Camping World RV, 8/25 – 🚨Used RV Markdown🚨
ModCloth, 8/4 – “Where’d you get that dress!?”
Express, 8/11 – New selfie-worthy Body Contour styles 🤳
Bass Pro Shops, 8/29 – Everything you need to prepare your meat
Uncommon Goods, 8/7 – A 🌟spotlight🌟 on favorites from our Black makers
Moosejaw, 8/26 – Meet our new friends at Black Outside, Inc.
Nintendo, 8/25 – My Nintendo and LEGO® VIP are teaming up!
Macy’s, 8/19 – Ta-da! Toys“R”Us is now at Macy’s!
Kohl’s Friends + Family, 8/27 – Shop Sephora at Kohl’s to find skincare for every age & every stage.
Target, 8/7 – Hearth & Hand with Magnolia: Fall collection 🍁
Saks Fifth Avenue, 8/10 – Hours left: Get 20% off when you create an account
New posts on EmailMarketingRules.com
Only Influencers’ Email Metrics Project: Ask the Right Email Questions
LiveIntent’s Real Time Banter Podcast: Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection
Audience Acquisition Source Ideas to Explore: An Oracle Consulting Checklist
How Many of My Subscribers Will Be Affected by Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection?
Hide My Email: A New Reason to Only Accept Corporate Email Addresses
The 7 Factors that Determine Email Deliverability
The 2 Social Contracts Being Broken by Apple’s New Privacy Protections
Email Marketing’s Increasing Role as Third-Party Cookies Disappear
Posted on September 1, 2021
While some think that Google giving marketers two more years to prepare for the depreciation of third-party cookies will lead to complacency, I hope that brands maintain the momentum of recent months. Without a doubt, this change across the entire online advertising industry is causing a major shift in digital advertising targeting and identity management. Every marketer would be wise to use this extra time to collect alternative IDs and more zero- and first-party data assets so they can continue to create effective ad campaigns. Email marketing will have a role to play in addressing both of those needs.
Let’s look at five ways that email marketing’s role will grow as priorities shift to cope with the sunsetting of third-party cookies…
Only Influencers’ Email Metrics Project: Ask the Right Email Questions
Posted on August 26, 2021
Email metrics are confusing and can be easily misunderstood and misused. To help marketers avoid mistakes, Only Influencers has launched The Email Metrics Project at oimetrics.com. This website is home to definitions, articles, and videos to educate marketers on how to calculate and appropriately use email marketing metrics.
I’m honored to have contributed several of my articles about email metrics, as well as recorded a video with Lauren Meyer about how marketers need to Ask The Right Email Questions when using email metrics. In that 26-minute video, we talk about:
- Common questions that email marketers ask that can lead to the wrong tactics and strategies
- The differences between business metrics and email metrics, and the differences between campaign, channels, and customer metrics
- How having a super-high ROI means you’re leaving tons of money on the table
- What marketers really want are insights, not data
- Why open rates are the most misunderstood email metric
- The usefulness of external benchmarks
- How to use internal benchmarks effectively
- And much more
>> Watch this 26-minute video on oimetrics.com
And for a much deeper dive into asking the right email questions, watch…
The Questions to Ask Instead: Email Performance Measurement
The Questions to Ask Instead: Email Frequency & List Building
Welcome! Email Marketing Rules is your guide to understanding the best practices of this complex, often misunderstood channel as you craft the best executions for your brand. Every week, we’ll explore strategies and tactics, discuss tips and inspiration, and dig into industry news and trends.
Chad S. White
Head of Research
Oracle Digital Experience Agency
Author of Email Marketing Rules and nearly 4,000 articles about digital and email marketing
